Indoor air pollutants and health in the United Arab Emirates
Dr. Yeatts, UNC Department of Epidemiology spoke on her project “Respiratory and neurologic effects of indoor SO2, NO2, H2S, CO, and HCHCO in a Gulf Arab Population”.
Dr. Yeatts evaluated human exposure to air pollutants in the United Arab Emirates (UAE), a country comprised of 7 emirates that include the towns of Dubai and Abu Dhabi. Due to oil reserves the UAE has gone from a nomadic people to skyscrapers in 40 years. Little to no research has been done on indoor air quality and human health. Using a population based survey strategy, Dr. Yeatts and her colleagues were able to recruit 600 households, a 75% response rate. A team of male and female interviewers assessed health based on the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES), including questions on chronic diseases (heart and lung), diet, lifestyle factors, socioeconomic factors. Each participating household had two visits separated by 7 days. A further 10 homes were chosen for 24-hour sampling of particulate matter, gases, temperature and relative humidity. At an additional 50 homes, outdoor samples were also taken of the 6 gases and particulate matter (PM). Her results are reported in Environmental Health Perspectives May 2012 issue (http://ehp03.niehs.nih.gov/article/fet chArticle.action?articleURI=info%3Adoi%2 F10.1289%2Fehp.1104090 ).
This study being a first of its kind, just the human information was fascinating. For example, main causes of death were cardiovascular, traffic accidents, and diabetes. By comparison, leading cases of mortality in the US are heart disease, cancer, and chronic lower respiratory disease (CDC 2009). As might be expected, there were important cultural issues that needed to be taken into account for a study of this type. Demographics differences included family sizes, which ranged from 6 to 25 individuals. Households had multiple wives, with the males and females residing in different sections of the house, meeting at a common room where sampling was set up. Only female interviewers (ie, if strangers, only female) were allowed in the common room. One of the main cultural differences was their attitude toward individuals. ‘Individuals as autonomous is not necessarily valid in societies where communal framework is the norm’. Another important difference is the culture of hospitality; interviewers were invited to stay for food, drink, even the night. Dr. Yeatts pointed out that holidays were based on the lunar calendar, so change every year, and no sampling should be done during the month of Ramadan, the month of fasting, as the whole society changes its behavior. Returning to the earlier comment about the immense changes over such a short time period, 13% of those surveyed were born nomadic, 50% lived in villas, 32% in government sponsored houses, and 0.8% in palace.
Results
Cooking was done with gas 60%, and 78% of households had a separate building for cooking. 35% of males smoke compared to 5% of women. However 44% of household report burning incense daily. Results show that the gas concentrations were fairly low, PM levels were high in 1/3 of the homes, PM levels lower indoors than outdoors. Health results showed wheezing levels similar to those of the US.
The researchers found some correlations between gas and symptoms, with increased wheezing and doctor-diagnosed asthma with increased gas concentration. No significant results were found between PM and health outcomes. There were however increased neurologic symptoms with increased incense burning or HCHO (formaldehyde) concentrations.
So, in summary, I found this to be a fascinating study, well presented.
Dr. Yeatts evaluated human exposure to air pollutants in the United Arab Emirates (UAE), a country comprised of 7 emirates that include the towns of Dubai and Abu Dhabi. Due to oil reserves the UAE has gone from a nomadic people to skyscrapers in 40 years. Little to no research has been done on indoor air quality and human health. Using a population based survey strategy, Dr. Yeatts and her colleagues were able to recruit 600 households, a 75% response rate. A team of male and female interviewers assessed health based on the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES), including questions on chronic diseases (heart and lung), diet, lifestyle factors, socioeconomic factors. Each participating household had two visits separated by 7 days. A further 10 homes were chosen for 24-hour sampling of particulate matter, gases, temperature and relative humidity. At an additional 50 homes, outdoor samples were also taken of the 6 gases and particulate matter (PM). Her results are reported in Environmental Health Perspectives May 2012 issue (http://ehp03.niehs.nih.gov/article/fet
This study being a first of its kind, just the human information was fascinating. For example, main causes of death were cardiovascular, traffic accidents, and diabetes. By comparison, leading cases of mortality in the US are heart disease, cancer, and chronic lower respiratory disease (CDC 2009). As might be expected, there were important cultural issues that needed to be taken into account for a study of this type. Demographics differences included family sizes, which ranged from 6 to 25 individuals. Households had multiple wives, with the males and females residing in different sections of the house, meeting at a common room where sampling was set up. Only female interviewers (ie, if strangers, only female) were allowed in the common room. One of the main cultural differences was their attitude toward individuals. ‘Individuals as autonomous is not necessarily valid in societies where communal framework is the norm’. Another important difference is the culture of hospitality; interviewers were invited to stay for food, drink, even the night. Dr. Yeatts pointed out that holidays were based on the lunar calendar, so change every year, and no sampling should be done during the month of Ramadan, the month of fasting, as the whole society changes its behavior. Returning to the earlier comment about the immense changes over such a short time period, 13% of those surveyed were born nomadic, 50% lived in villas, 32% in government sponsored houses, and 0.8% in palace.
Results
Cooking was done with gas 60%, and 78% of households had a separate building for cooking. 35% of males smoke compared to 5% of women. However 44% of household report burning incense daily. Results show that the gas concentrations were fairly low, PM levels were high in 1/3 of the homes, PM levels lower indoors than outdoors. Health results showed wheezing levels similar to those of the US.
The researchers found some correlations between gas and symptoms, with increased wheezing and doctor-diagnosed asthma with increased gas concentration. No significant results were found between PM and health outcomes. There were however increased neurologic symptoms with increased incense burning or HCHO (formaldehyde) concentrations.
So, in summary, I found this to be a fascinating study, well presented.